When Copying Becomes the Norm: What Future for Intellectual Property Revenue?

Muriel Roulleaux - Founder of Rightkeeper

An Idea That Is Taking Hold: Everything Can Be Copied

For a long time, creation relied on a simple balance: the person who creates owns the work, and the person who uses it must ask for permission, pay for a license, or enter into a contractual agreement. This model shaped entire industries, from music and software to design.

But over the past few years, a new idea has progressively emerged: copying has become inevitable. With the rise of artificial intelligence, everything can seemingly be reproduced, remixed, transformed, and replicated almost instantly.

This vision is appealing because of its simplicity. It follows an apparently logical assumption:
if everything can be copied, then protecting creative work no longer matters.

And yet, this idea is misleading — and potentially destructive for the creative economy.

Behind Intellectual Property Lies an Economy

Intellectual property is not merely a legal issue.
Above all, it is an economic one.

Behind every creation lies an entire value chain: revenue, licensing, usage rights, investment, and monetization. Weakening or removing protection directly destabilizes that chain.

If creations can be freely copied without consequence, their value inevitably declines. And with it, the ability of creators and businesses to generate income from their work.

The Normalization of “Everything Is Reusable”

With generative AI, a new norm is emerging.

Everything appears:
reusable,
duplicable,
transformable,
instantly accessible.

This evolution creates a collective illusion: the idea that creative work no longer needs protection.

But economic history suggests the opposite.
The more accessible a resource becomes, the more it must be structured and protected in order to retain value.

What Happens If Protection Disappears?

Imagining a world without intellectual property protection helps reveal what is truly at stake.

Without a framework:

  • creators’ revenues collapse,
  • freelancers lose the ability to monetize their work,
  • innovative companies see their products copied within days,
  • investment in research and development declines.

Ultimately, the entire creative ecosystem becomes weaker:
less incentive to create,
less innovation,
more opportunism.

AI Does Not Eliminate Value — It Shifts It

Artificial intelligence is profoundly transforming the way content is produced. It accelerates, automates, and reshapes creative processes.

But it does not eliminate the concept of ownership.

On the contrary, it reinforces a fundamental reality:
in a world where everything can be copied, value increasingly depends on what can be proven.

Prior ownership becomes central.

Being able to demonstrate that a piece of content existed at a specific date and was linked to a particular creator becomes a decisive factor.

Proof Becomes the New Strategic Asset

This shift is already visible.

Companies are placing growing importance on:

  • content traceability,
  • license management,
  • proof of data origin.

Creators, meanwhile, are facing a growing number of disputes:
work reused without permission,
ideas appropriated,
deliverables exploited without payment.

In this context, proof is no longer a minor legal detail.
It becomes an asset.

Two Possible Futures for the Creative Economy

The current evolution opens the door to two possible trajectories.

In the first scenario, copying becomes uncontrollable. Everything circulates without structure, creators lose revenue, companies stop investing, and innovation slows down.

In the second scenario, creation becomes documented, traceable, and certified. Every work is associated with evidence, exchanges are structured, and licensing ecosystems expand.

In this model, value does not disappear.
It becomes stronger.

The Key Role of Prior Ownership

In both scenarios, one factor makes all the difference:
the ability to prove.

To prove that a file existed.
To prove it was created first.
To prove its origin.

This logic fundamentally transforms the way intellectual property is protected.

The goal is no longer simply to prevent copying.
It is to document creation itself.

Toward a Traceable Creative Economy

New solutions are emerging to address this transformation.

By associating a file with a timestamp and a digital fingerprint, it becomes possible to create proof of existence. This proof can then support traceability in the event of disputes or contractual negotiations.

This is notably the approach of platforms such as Rightkeeper, which transform creative work into a documented asset.

Protecting Creation to Keep Creating

Intellectual property is not an obstacle to innovation.
It is one of its conditions.

Without protection, creation loses its economic value.
Without value, it loses its attractiveness.
And without attractiveness, it gradually disappears from sustainable business models.

In a world where copying has become fast and effortless, the question is no longer whether protection is necessary.

The real question is how to protect effectively.